Recipe: Pulled Beef
Recipe Source: Based on a post made by 'Fishlessman' on the Greeneggers.com forum at http://www.greeneggers.com/index.php?option=com_simpleboard&func=view&id=103156&catid=1
I had seen a reference to this recipe a while back while perusing the Greeneggers.com online forum and I had bookmarked it to go back and try it later. I was at the butcher shop recently picking up some meat for another recipe when I saw some really nice looking chuck roasts on the shelf, so I decided to grab one and finally test this recipe out. Jess was going to be coming home from a weekend of bringing Fearless Baby to see Grandma and Grandpa, so I thought it would be nice to have dinner for them when they got back. My roast was about 3.5 lbs, so we invited some friends over to eat it with us.
I mostly followed the recipe as written since I hadn't ever tried making anything like this before. I left out the Guinness in the drip pan that the original poster suggested, as I didn't think that would add much to the flavor and frankly would rather drink the beer. I rubbed the meat with some Dizzy Pig BBQ Dizzy Dust that I had on hand, and put it in the smoker with some oak wood chunks for smoke. I left off the additional sugar that the original author used, both because the rub I used already contained some sugar and because Jess doesn't like things sweet. I also left out the seltzer that the original author mixed with the sauce while wrapping, as I didn't have any handy. t used my Maverick ET-73 remote thermometer to keep track of the temperature, since I really had no idea how long this would take to cook. I estimated it would take about 90 minutes / lb, which is my usual rule of thumb for brisket, but it took it's time getting up to the 170 degree mark. Once wrapped in foil however, the temperature came up quickly. The total cook time ended up around 7 hours, or about 2 hours per pound.
I made a few changes to the sauce as well. The original called for an equal mix of mojo sauce (a lime-juice, olive oil, and garlic based sauce), cider vinegar, and white vinegar as a base. However, when I started to mix it up, I realized we were out of cider vinegar, and I really had no desire to go back to the store. I ended up using 2 parts white vinegar to 1 part fresh lime juice, and mixed in some other ingredients I had on hand to approximate the original. One other change I made was substituting chipotle powder for the cayenne pepper, both because I think it is more flavorful and because one of my guests doesn't like things overly spicy, and the chipotle is somewhat milder than the cayenne.
Overall, this recipe was a big success. The meat was flavorful and juicy, the sauce tasted great, and everyone really enjoyed it, including Fearless Baby, who kept asking for 'more meat'! We thought it was a great substitute, albeit a more expensive one, for pulled pork, which we can't eat anymore due to the pork allergy Jess developed. The meat seemed a little fattier than I expected. I'm not sure if that was the particular piece of meat I got, or if it's just a difference in how fat renders off of beef as opposed to pork. It was still really good, and I'll definitely be serving this again when I can find this cut of beef.
Pulled Beef (Serves 4-6. Approx. Cost per Serving Not Available)
Equipment Required
- Big Green Egg or Other Smoker
- Aluminum Foil
- Remote Thermometer (recommended)
3 1/2 to 4 pound beef chuck roast
Yellow mustard
Your choice of spice rub
Hamburger rolls
For the Sauce
1/2 cup lime juice
1 cup white vinegar
1 tablespoon hot sauce1 tablespoon chipotle powder
1/2 tablespoon black pepper1/2 tablespoon garlic powder
1/2 tablesppon turbinado sugar
1/2 teaspoon salt
1 tablespoon chopped fresh cilantro
1 tablespoon olive oil
1) Calculate your cooking time, using an estimate of approximately 2 hours per pound of actual time in the smoker, plus the lead time for the smoker to heat up, and at least 30-60 minutes to let the meat rest after removing it from the smoker.
2) At the appropriate time, start up your smoker and set it up to cook at 250 degrees Fahrenheit. In my large Big Green Egg, I set up for indirect cooking, and added some oak chunks to my fire for smoke flavor.
3) While the smoker is coming up to temperature, prepare your meat. Sprinkle the meat with your spice rub, then add a thin layer of yellow mustard, and liberally apply more spice rub. This helps create a nice flavorful bark on the outside of the meat. Don't worry - it won't taste like mustard.
4) When the smoker's temperature has stabilized at 250 degrees, put in the meat. I strongly recommend using a remote thermometer to monitor your progress, so you aren't constantly having to check on it.
5) While the meat is cooking, mix together the ingredients for your sauce in a bowl, whisk together, and set aside.
6) When your meat's internal temperature reaches 170 degrees Fahrenheit, lay out some aluminum foil on a work surface, remove the beef and place on the foil. Turn up the edges and pour about 1/4 of the sauce over the meat. Wrap tightly, add another layer of foil, and return to the smoker.
7) When the internal temperature of the meat reaches 205 degrees Fahrenheit, remove from the smoker, cover the foil-wrapped meat in a cloth towel, and move to a cooler to rest for at least 30 minutes. With pulled pork, you can keep warm and ready to pull this way for up to 4 hours. I assume it would be similar with this recipe, but we were hungry, and I only let mine rest for 30 minutes.
8) Carefully unwrap the meat from the foil, and using two forks, pull the meat apart until it is well shredded. Serve on hamburger rolls, with the remaining sauce on the side.